Patch angioplasty is the most common technique used for the performance of carotid endarterectomy. A large number of patching materials are available for use while new materials are being continuously developed. Surprisingly little is known about the mechanical properties of these materials and how these properties compare with those of the carotid artery wall. Mismatch of the mechanical properties can produce mechanical and hemodynamic effects that may compromise the long-term patency of the endarterectomized arterial segment. The aim of this paper was to systematically evaluate and compare the biaxial mechanical behavior of the most commonly used patching materials. We compared PTFE (n = 1), Dacron (n = 2), bovine pericardium (n = 10), autogenous greater saphenous vein (n = 10), and autogenous external jugular vein (n = 9) with the wall of the common carotid artery (n = 18). All patching materials were found to be significantly stiffer than the carotid wall in both the longitudinal and circumferential directions. Synthetic patches demonstrated the most mismatch in stiffness values and vein patches the least mismatch in stiffness values compared to those of the native carotid artery. All biological materials, including the carotid artery, demonstrated substantial nonlinearity, anisotropy, and variability; however, the behavior of biological and biologically-derived patches was both qualitatively and quantitatively different from the behavior of the carotid wall. The majority of carotid arteries tested were stiffer in the circumferential direction, while the opposite anisotropy was observed for all types of vein patches and bovine pericardium. The rates of increase in the nonlinear stiffness over the physiological stress range were also different for the carotid and patching materials. Several carotid wall samples exhibited reverse anisotropy compared to the average behavior of the carotid tissue. A similar characteristic was observed for two of 19 vein patches. The obtained results quantify, for the first time, significant mechanical dissimilarity of the currently available patching materials and the carotid artery. The results can be used as guidance for designing more efficient patches with mechanical properties resembling those of the carotid wall. The presented systematic comparative mechanical analysis of the existing patching materials provides valuable information for patch selection in the daily practice of carotid surgery and can be used in future clinical studies comparing the efficacy of different patches in the performance of carotid endarterectomy.
Issue Section:
Research Papers
References
1.
ACCF/SCAI/SVMB/SIR/ASITN
, 2007, “Clinical Expert Consensus Document on Carotid Stenting: A Report of the American College of Cardiology Foundation Task Force on Clinical Expert Consensus Documents (ACCF/SCAI/SVMB/SIR/ASITN Clinical Expert Consensus Document Committee on Carotid Stenting
,” Vasc. Med.
12
, pp. 35
–83
.2.
Ricotta
, J. J.
, and Piazza
, M.
, 2010, “Carotid Endarterectomy or Carotid Artery Stenting? Matching the Patient to the Intervention
,” Perspect. Vasc. Surg. Endovasc. Ther.
, 22
(2
), pp.124
–136
.3.
Muto
, A.
, Nishibe
, T.
, Dardik
, H.
, and Dardik
, A.
, 2009, “Patches for Carotid Artery Endarterectomy: Current Materials and Prospects
,” J. Vasc. Surg.
, 50
(1
), pp. 206
–213
.4.
Awad
, I. A.
, and Little
J. R.
, 1989, “Patch Angioplasty in Carotid Endarterectomy. Advantages, Concerns, and Controversies
,” Stroke
, 20
(3
), pp. 417
–422
.5.
AbuRahma
, A. F.
, Robinson
, P. A.
, Saiedy
, S.
, Kahn
, J. H.
, and Boland
J. P.
, 1998, “Prospective Randomized Trial of Carotid Endarterectomy with Primary Closure and Patch Angioplasty with Saphenous Vein, Jugular Vein, and Polytetrafluoroethylene: Long-Term Follow-Up
,” J. Vasc. Surg.
, 27
(2
), pp. 222
–234
.6.
Letter
, J. A. D.
, Moll
, F. L.
, Welten
, R. J.
, Eikelboom
, B. C.
, Ackerstaff
, R. G.
, Vermeulen
F. E.
, and Algra
, A.
, 1994, “Benefits of Carotid Patching: A Prospective Randomized Study with Long-Term Follow-Up
,” Ann. Vasc. Surg.
, 8
(1
), pp. 54
–58
.7.
Myers
, S. I.
, Valentine
, R. J.
, Chervu
, A.
, Bowers
, B. L.
, and Clagett
, G. P.
, 1994, “Saphenous Vein Patch Versus Primary Closure for Carotid Endarterectomy: Long-Term Assessment of a Randomized Prospective Study
,” J. Vasc. Surg.
, 19
(1
), pp. 15
–22
.8.
Bond
, R.
, Rerkasem
, K.
, Naylor
, A. R.
, Aburahma
, A. F.
, and Rothwell
, P. M.
, 2004, “Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials of Patch Angioplasty versus Primary Closure and Different Types of Patch Materials during Carotid Endarterectomy
,” J. Vasc. Surg.
, 40
(6
), pp. 1126
–1135
.9.
Rockman
, C. B.
, Halm
, E. A.
, Wang
, J. J.
, Chassin
, M. R.
, Tuhrim
, S.
, Formisano
, P.
, and Riles
, T. S.
, 2005, “Primary Closure of the Carotid Artery is Associated with Poorer Outcomes during Carotid Endarterectomy
,” J. Vasc. Surg.
, 42
(5
), pp. 870
–877
.10.
Dobson
, G.
, Flewitt
, J.
, Tyberg
, J. V.
, Moore
, R.
, and Karamanoglu
, M.
, 2006, “Endografting of the Descending Thoracic Aorta Increases Ascending Aortic Input Impedance and Attenuates Pressure Transmission in Dogs
,” Eur. J. Vasc. Endovasc. Surg.
, 32
(2
), pp. 129
–135
.11.
Kim
, S. Y.
, Hinkamp
, T. J.
, Jacobs
, W. R.
, Lichtenberg
, R. C.
, Posniak
, H.
, and Pifarr
, R.
, 1995, “Effect of an Inelastic Aortic Synthetic Vascular Graft on Exercise Hemodynamics
,” Ann. Thorac. Surg.
, 59
(4
), pp.981
–989
.12.
Stewart
, S.
, and Lyman
, D.
, 1992, “Effects of a Vascular Graft/Natural Artery Compliance Mismatch on Pulsatile Flow
,” J. Biomech.
, 25
, pp. 297
–310
.13.
Miyawaki
, F.
, and How
, T. D. A.
, 1990, “Effect of Compliance Mismatch on Flow Disturbances in a Model of an Arterial Graft Replacement
,” Med. Biol. Eng. Comput.
, 28
, pp. 457
–464
.14.
Ballyk
, P. D.
, Walsh
, C.
, Butany
, J.
, and Ojha
, M.
, 1998, “Compliance Mismatch May Promote Graft-Artery Intimal Hyperplasia by Altering Suture-Line Stresses
,” J. Biomech.
, 31
(3
), pp. 229
–237
.15.
Surovtsova
, I.
, 2005, “Effects of Compliance Mismatch on Blood Flow in an Artery with Endovascular Prosthesis
,” J. Biomech.
, 38
, pp. 2078
–2086
.16.
Kamenskiy
, A. V.
, Pipinos
, I. I.
, Desyatova
, A. S.
, Salkovskiy
, Y. E.
, Kossovich
, L. Y.
, Kirillova
, I. V.
, Bockeria
, L. A.
, Morozov
, K. M.
, Polyaev
V. O.
, Lynch
, T. G.
, and Dzenis
, Y. A.
, 2009, “Finite Element Model of the Patched Human Carotid
,” Vasc. Endovascular Surg.
, 43
(6
), pp. 533
–541
.17.
Scales
, J. T.
, 1953, “Tissue Reactions to Synthetic Materials
,” Proc. R. Soc. Med.
, 46
(8
), pp. 647
–652
.18.
Tremblay
, D.
, Zigras
, T.
, Cartier
, R.
, Leduc
, L.
, Butany
, J.
, Mongrain
, R.
, and Leask
, R. L.
, 2009, “A Comparison of Mechanical Properties of Materials used in Aortic Arch Reconstruction
,” Ann. Thorac. Surg.
, 88
(5
), pp. 1484
–1491
.19.
Bond
, R.
, Rerkasem
, K.
, Naylor
, R.
, and Rothwell
, P. M.
, 2004, “Patches of Different Types for Carotid Patch Angioplasty
,” Cochrane Database Syst. Rev.
, 2
, p. CD000071
.20.
AbuRahma
, A. F.
, Stone
, P. A.
, Flaherty
, S. K.
, and AbuRahma
, Z.
, 2007, “Prospective Randomized Trial of ACUSEAL (Gore-Tex) versus Hemashield-Finesse Patching during Carotid Endarterectomy: Early Results
,” J. Vasc. Surg.
, 45
(5
), pp. 881
–884
.21.
Naylor
, R.
, Hayes
, P. D.
, Payne
, D. A.
, Allroggen
, H.
, Steel
, S.
, Thompson
, M. M.
, London
, N. J.
, and Bell
, P. R.
, 2004, “Randomized Trial of Vein versus Dacron Patching During Carotid Endarterectomy: Long-Term Results
,” J. Vasc. Surg.
, 39
(5
), pp. 985
–993
.22.
O’Hara
, P. J.
, Hertzer
, N. R.
, Mascha
, E. J.
, Krajewski
, L. P.
, Clair
, D. G.
, and Ouriel
, K.
, 2002, “A Prospective, Randomized Study of Saphenous Vein Patching versus Synthetic Patching during Carotid Endarterectomy
,” J. Vasc. Surg.
, 35
(2
), pp. 324
–332
.23.
Purinya
, B. A.
, and Kas’yanov
, V. A.
, 1977, “Changes in the Mechanical Properties of Human Coronary Arteries with Age
,” Mech. Compos. Mater.
, 13
(2
), pp. 251
–255
.24.
Holzapfel
, G. A.
, Sommer
, G.
, Gasser
, C. T.
, and Regitnig
, P.
, 2005, “Determination of Layer-Specific Mechanical Properties of Human Coronary Arteries with Nonatherosclerotic Intimal Thickening and Related Constitutive Modeling
,” Am. J. Physiol. Heart Circ. Physiol.
, 289
(5
), pp. H2048
–H2058
.25.
Patel
, D. J.
, and Janicki
J. S.
, 1970, “Static Elastic Properties of the Left Coronary Circumflex Artery and the Common Carotid Artery in Dogs
,” Circ. Res.
, 27
(2
), pp. 149
–158
.26.
Sacks
, M. S.
, 2000, “Biaxial Mechanical Evaluation of Planar Biological Materials
,” J. Elast.
, 61
, pp. 199
–246
.27.
Grashow
, J. S.
, 2005, “Evaluation of the Biaxial Mechanical Properties of the Mitral Valve Anterior Leaflet Under Physiological Loading Conditions
,” Master’s thesis, University of Pittsburgh.28.
Geest
, J. P. V.
, Sacks
, M. S.
, and Vorp
, D. A.
, 2006, “The Effects of Aneurysm on the Biaxial Mechanical Behavior of Human Abdominal Aorta
,” J. Biomech.
, 39
(7
), pp. 1324
–1334
.29.
Geest
, J. P. V.
, Sacks
, M. S.
, and Vorp
, D. A.
, 2004, “Age Dependency of the Biaxial Biomechanical Behavior of Human Abdominal Aorta
,” J. Biomech. Eng.
, 126
(6
), pp. 815
–822
.30.
Fung
, Y. C.
, 1993, Biomechanics: Mechanical Properties of Living Tissue
, Springer-Verlag
, New York
.31.
Sacks
, M. S.
, and Chuong
, C. J.
, 1998, “Orthotropic Mechanical Properties of Chemically Treated Bovine Pericardium
,” Ann. Biomed. Eng.
, 26
, pp. 892
–902
.32.
Lysle
, H. P.
, Roderick
, E. J.
, and Parnell
, J.
, 1960, “Mechanical Properties of Arteries in vivo
,” Circ. Res.
, 8
, pp. 622
–639
.33.
Dobrin
, P. B.
, and Mrkvicka
, R.
, 1992, “Estimating the Elastic Modulus of Non-Atherosclerotic Elastic Arteries
,” J. Hypertens. Suppl.
, 10
(6
), pp. S7
–S10
.34.
Cox
, R. H.
, 1975, “Anisotropic Properties of the Canine Carotid Artery in Vitro
,” J. Biomech.
, 8
, pp. 293
–300
.35.
Fung
, Y. C.
, Fronek
, K.
, and Patitucci
, P.
, 1979, “Pseudoelasticity of Arteries and the Choice of its Mathematical Expression
,” Am. J. Physiol.
, 237
, pp. H620
–H631
.36.
Delfino
, A.
, 1996, “Analysis of Stress Field in a Model of the Human Carotid Bifurcation
,” Ph.D. thesis, Ecole Polytechnique Federale DeLausanne, Lausanne.37.
Gupta
, B. S.
, and Kasyanov
, V. A.
, 1997, “Biomechanics of Human Common Carotid Artery and Design of Novel Hybrid Textile Compliant Vascular Grafts
,” J. Biomed. Mater. Res.
, 34
(3
), pp. 341
–349
.38.
Sommer
, G.
, Regitnig
, P.
, Koltringer
, L.
, and Holzapfel
, G. A.
, 2009, “Biaxial Mechanical Properties of Intact and Layer-Dissected Human Carotid Arteries at Physiological and Supra-Physiological Loadings
,” Am. J. Physiol. Heart Circ. Physiol.
, 298
(3
), pp. H898
–H912
.39.
Kasyanov
, V.
, Ozolanta
, I.
, Purinya
, B.
, Ozols
, A.
, and Kancevich
, V.
, 2003, “Compliance of a Biocomposite Vascular Tissue in Longitudinal and Circumferential Directions as a Basis for Creating Artificial Substitutes
,” Mech. Compos. Mater.
39
(4
), pp. 347
–358
.40.
Holzapfel
, G. A.
, Gasser
, T. C.
, and Ogden
, R. W.
, 2000, “A New Constitutive Framework for Arterial Wall Mechanics and a Comparative Study of Material Models
,” J. Elast.
, 61
, pp. 1
–48
.41.
Gasser
, T. C.
, Ogden
, R. W.
, and Holzapfel
G. A.
, 2006, “Hyperelastic Modeling of Arterial Layers with Distributed Collagen Fibre Orientations
,” J. R. Soc., Interface
, 3
, pp. 15
–35
.42.
van Oijen
C. H. G. A.
, van de Vosse
, F. N.
, and Baaijens
, F. P. T.
, 2003, Mechanics and Design of Fiber-Reinforced Vascular Prostheses
, Technische Universiteit Eindhoven.43.
Kowligi
, R. R.
, Taylor
, H. H.
, and Wollner
, S. A.
, 1993, “Physical Properties and Testing Methods for PTFE Cardiovascular Patches
,” J. Biomater. Appl.
, 7
(4
), pp. 353
–361
.44.
Lee
, J. M.
, and Wilson
G. J.
, 1986, “Anisotropic Tensile Viscoelastic Properties of Vascular Graft Materials Tested at Low Strain Rates
,” Biomaterials
7
(6
), pp. 423
–431
.45.
Chen
, C.
, and Lumsden
A. B.
, 2004, “Decellularized Vascular Prostheses Resistant To Thrombus Occlusion And Immunologic Rejection
,” U.S. Patent No. 6689161.46.
Hasegawa
, M.
, and Azuma
, T.
, 1979, “Mechanical Properties of Synthetic Arterial Grafts
,” J. Biomech.
, 12
(7
), pp. 509
–517
.47.
Kim
, G. E.
, Kwon
, T. W.
, Cho
, Y. P.
, Kim
, D. K.
, and Kim
, H. S.
, 2001, “Carotid Endarterectomy with Bovine Patch Angioplasty: A Preliminary Report
,” Cardiovasc. Surg.
, 9
(5
), pp. 458
–462
.48.
Hines
, G. L.
, Feuerman
, M.
, Cappello
, D.
, and Cruz
, V.
, 2007, “Results of Carotid Endarterectomy with Pericardial Patch Angioplasty: Rate and Predictors of Restenosis
,” Ann. Vasc. Surg.
, 21
(6
), pp. 767
–771
.49.
Lee
, J. M.
, Ku
, M.
, and Haberer
, S. A.
, 1989, “The Bovine Pericardial Xenograft: III. Effect of Uniaxial and Sequential Biaxial Stress during Fixation on the Tensile Viscoelastic Properties of Bovine Pericardium
,” J. Biomed. Mater. Res.
, 23
(5
), pp. 491
–506
.50.
Berguer
, R.
, and Kieffer
, E.
, 1992, Surgery of the Arteries to the Head
, Springer-Verlag
, New York
.51.
Yamamoto
, Y.
, Piepgras
, D. G.
, Marsh
, W. R.
, and Meyer
, F. B.
, 1996, “Complications Resulting from Saphenous Vein Patch Graft after Carotid Endarterectomy
,” Neurosurgery
, 39
(4
), pp. 670
–676
.52.
Wesly
, R. L.
, Vaishnav
, R. N.
, Fuchs
, J. C.
, Patel
, D. J.
, and Greenfield
, J. C.
, 1975, “Static Linear and Nonlinear Elastic Properties of Normal and Arterialized Venous Tissue in Dog and Man
,” Circ. Res.
, 37
(4
), pp. 509
–520
.53.
Abbott
, W. M.
, Megerman
, J.
, Hasson
, J. E.
, L’Italien
, G.
, and Warnock
, D. F.
, 1987, “Effect of Compliance Mismatch on Vascular Graft Patency
,” J. Vasc. Surg.
, 5
(2
), pp. 376
–382
.54.
Weston
, M. W.
, Rhee
, K.
, and Tarbell
, J. M.
, 1996, “Compliance and Diameter Mismatch Affect the Wall Shear Rate Distribution near an End-To-End Anastomosis
,” J. Biomech.
, 29
(2
), pp. 187
–198
.55.
Costello
, J. R.
, 2004, “The Effect of Material Properties and Hemodynamics on Healing of Vascular Grafts in Baboons
,” Ph.D. Thesis, Georgia Institute of Technology.56.
Zaucha
, M. T.
, Gauvin
, R.
, Auger
, F. A.
, Germain
, L.
, and Gleason
, R. L.
, 2011, “Biaxial Biomechanical Properties of Self-Assembly Tissue-Engineered Blood Vessels
,” J. R. Soc., Interface
, 8
(55
), pp. 244
–256
.57.
Konig
, G.
, McAllister
, T. N.
, Dusserre
, N.
, Garrido
, S. A.
, Iyican
, C.
, Marini
, A.
, Fiorillo
, A.
, Avila
, H.
, Wystrychowski
, W.
, Zagalski
, K.
, Maruszewski
, M.
, Jones
, A. L.
, Cierpka
, L.
, de la Fuente
, L. M.
, and L’Heureux
, N.
, 2009, “Mechanical Properties of Completely Autologous Human Tissue Engineered Blood Vessels Compared to Human Saphenous Vein and Mammary Artery
,” Biomaterials
, 30
(8
), pp. 1542
–1550
.58.
Courtney
, T.
, Sacks
, M. S.
, Stankus
, J.
, Guan
, J.
, and Wagner
, W. R.
, 2006, “Design and Analysis of Tissue Engineering Scaffolds that Mimic Soft Tissue Mechanical Anisotropy
,” Biomaterials
, 27
(19
), pp. 3631
–3638
.59.
Yang
, J.
, Motlagh
, D.
, Webb
, A. R.
, and Ameer
, G. A.
, 2005, “Novel Biphasic Elastomeric Scaffold for Small-Diameter Blood Vessel Tissue Engineering
,” Tissue Eng.
, 11
(11–12
), pp. 1876
–1886
.60.
Mertsching
, H.
, Walles
, T.
, Hofmann
, M.
, Schanz
, J.
, and Knapp
W. H.
, 2005, “Engineering of a Vascularized Scaffold for Artificial Tissue and Organ Generation
,” Biomaterials
, 26
(33
), pp. 6610
–6617
.Copyright © 2011
by American Society of Mechanical Engineers
You do not currently have access to this content.
