Abstract
Functional electrical stimulation (FES) is often used in poststroke gait rehabilitation to address decreased walking speed, foot drop, and decreased forward propulsion. However, not all individuals experience clinically meaningful improvements in gait function with stimulation. Previous research has developed adaptive functional electrical stimulation (AFES) systems that adjust stimulation timing and amplitude at every stride to deliver optimal stimulation. The purpose of this work was to determine the effects of a novel AFES system on functional gait outcomes and compare them to the effects of the existing FES system. Twenty-four individuals with chronic poststroke hemiparesis completed 64-min walking trials on an adaptive and fixed-speed treadmill with no stimulation, stimulation from the existing FES system, and stimulation from the AFES system. There was no significant effect of stimulation condition on walking speed, peak dorsiflexion angle, or peak propulsive force. Walking speed was significantly faster and peak propulsive force was significantly larger on the adaptive treadmill (ATM) than the fixed-speed treadmill (both p < 0.0001). Dorsiflexor stimulation timing was similar between stimulation conditions, but plantarflexor stimulation timing was significantly improved with the AFES system compared to the FES system (p = 0.0059). Variability between and within subjects was substantial, and some subjects experienced clinically meaningful improvements in walking speed, peak dorsiflexion angle, and peak propulsive force. However, not all subjects experienced benefits, suggesting that further research to characterize which subjects exhibit the best instantaneous response to FES is needed to optimize poststroke gait rehabilitation using FES.
References
1.
Benjamin
, E. J.
, Muntner
, P.
, Alonso
, A.
, Bittencourt
, M. S.
, Callaway
, C. W.
, Carson
, A. P.
, Chamberlain
, A. M.
, et al., 2019
, “Heart Disease and Stroke Statistics-2019 Update: A Report From the American Heart Association
,” Circulation
, 139
(10
), pp. e56
–e528
.10.1161/CIR.00000000000006592.
Dickstein
, R.
, 2008
, “Rehabilitation of Gait Speed After Stroke: A Critical Review of Intervention Approaches
,” Neurorehabil. Neural Repair
, 22
(6
), pp. 649
–660
.10.1177/15459683083159973.
Roelker
, S. A.
, Bowden
, M. G.
, Kautz
, S. A.
, and Neptune
, R. R.
, 2019
, “Paretic Propulsion as a Measure of Walking Performance and Functional Motor Recovery Post-Stroke: A Review
,” Gait Posture
, 68
, pp. 6
–14
.10.1016/j.gaitpost.2018.10.0274.
Patterson
, S. L.
, Forrester
, L. W.
, Rodgers
, M. M.
, Ryan
, A. S.
, Ivey
, F. M.
, Sorkin
, J. D.
, and Macko
, R. F.
, 2007
, “Determinants of Walking Function After Stroke: Differences by Deficit Severity
,” Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil.
, 88
(1
), pp. 115
–119
.10.1016/j.apmr.2006.10.0255.
Lynch
, C. L.
, and Popovic
, M. R.
, 2008
, “Functional Electrical Stimulation
,” IEEE Control Syst.
, 28
(2
), pp. 40
–50
.10.1109/MCS.2007.914689.6.
Awad
, L. N.
, Lewek
, M. D.
, Kesar
, T. M.
, Franz
, J. R.
, and Bowden
, M. G.
, 2020
, “These Legs Were Made for Propulsion: Advancing the Diagnosis and Treatment of Post-Stroke Propulsion Deficits
,” J. NeuroEng. Rehabil.
, 17
(1
), Article No. 139.10.1186/s12984-020-00747-67.
Bohannon
, R. W.
, Morton
, M. G.
, and Wikholm
, J. B.
, 1991
, “Importance of Four Variables of Walking to Patients With Stroke
,” Int. J. Rehabil. Res.
, 14
(3
), pp. 246
–250
.10.1097/00004356-199109000-000108.
Jørgensen
, H. S.
, Nakayama
, H.
, Raaschou
, H. O.
, and Olsen
, T. S.
, 1995
, “Recovery of Walking Function in Stroke Patients: The Copenhagen Stroke Study
,” Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil.
, 76
(1
), pp. 27
–32
.10.1016/S0003-9993(95)80038-79.
Langhorne
, P.
, Coupar
, F.
, and Pollock
, A.
, 2009
, “Motor Recovery After Stroke: A Systematic Review
,” Lancet Neurol.
, 8
(8
), pp. 741
–754
.10.1016/S1474-4422(09)70150-410.
Kesar
, T. M.
, Perumal
, R.
, Reisman
, D. S.
, Jancosko
, A.
, Rudolph
, K. S.
, Higginson
, J. S.
, and Binder-Macleod
, S. A.
, 2009
, “Functional Electrical Stimulation of Ankle Plantarflexor and Dorsiflexor Muscles: Effects on Poststroke Gait
,” Stroke
, 40
(12
), pp. 3821
–3827
.10.1161/STROKEAHA.109.56037511.
Li
, S.
, Francisco
, G. E.
, and Zhou
, P.
, 2018
, “Post-Stroke Hemiplegic Gait: New Perspective and Insights
,” Front. Physiol.
, 9
, pp. 1
–8
.10.3389/fphys.2018.0102112.
Bowden
, M. G.
, Balasubramanian
, C. K.
, Neptune
, R. R.
, and Kautz
, S. A.
, 2006
, “Anterior-Posterior Ground Reaction Forces as a Measure of Paretic Leg Contribution in Hemiparetic Walking
,” Stroke
, 37
(3
), pp. 872
–876
.10.1161/01.STR.0000204063.75779.8d13.
Allen
, J. L.
, Ting
, L. H.
, and Kesar
, T. M.
, 2018
, “Gait Rehabilitation Using Functional Electrical Stimulation Induces Changes in Ankle Muscle Coordination in Stroke Survivors: A Preliminary Study
,” Front. Neurol.
, 9
, p. 1127
.10.3389/fneur.2018.0112714.
Reisman
, D. S.
, Kesar
, T. M.
, Perumal
, R.
, Roos
, M.
, Rudolph
, K. S.
, Higginson
, J. S.
, Helm
, E.
, and Binder-Macleod
, S. A.
, 2013
, “Time Course of Functional and Biomechanical Improvements During a Gait Training Intervention in Persons With Chronic Stroke
,” J. Neurol. Phys. Ther.
, 37
(4
), pp. 159
–165
.10.1097/NPT.000000000000002015.
Kesar
, T. M.
, Reisman
, D. S.
, Perumal
, R.
, Jancosko
, A. M.
, Higginson
, J. S.
, Rudolph
, K. S.
, and Binder-Macleod
, S. A.
, 2011
, “Combined Effects of Fast Treadmill Walking and Functional Electrical Stimulation on Post-Stroke Gait
,” Gait Posture
, 33
(2
), pp. 309
–313
.10.1016/j.gaitpost.2010.11.01916.
Ray
, N. T.
, Reisman
, D. S.
, and Higginson
, J. S.
, 2021
, “Combined User-Driven Treadmill Control and Functional Electrical Stimulation Increases Walking Speeds Poststroke
,” J. Biomech.
, 124
, p. 110480
.10.1016/j.jbiomech.2021.11048017.
Embrey
, D. G.
, Holtz
, S. L.
, Alon
, G.
, Brandsma
, B. A.
, and McCoy
, S. W.
, 2010
, “Functional Electrical Stimulation to Dorsiflexors and Plantar Flexors During Gait to Improve Walking in Adults With Chronic Hemiplegia
,” Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil.
, 91
(5
), pp. 687
–696
.10.1016/j.apmr.2009.12.02418.
Jiang
, C.
, Zheng
, M.
, Li
, Y.
, Wang
, X.
, Li
, L.
, and Song
, R.
, 2020
, “Iterative Adjustment of Stimulation Timing and Intensity During FES-Assisted Treadmill Walking for Patients After Stroke
,” IEEE Trans. Neural Syst. Rehabil. Eng.
, 28
(6
), pp. 1292
–1298
.10.1109/TNSRE.2020.298629519.
Seel
, T.
, Laidig
, D.
, Valtin
, M.
, Werner
, C.
, Raisch
, J. J.
, and Schauer
, T.
, 2014
, “Feedback Control of Foot Eversion in the Adaptive Peroneal Stimulator
,” 2014 22nd Mediterranean Conference on Control and Automation
, Palermo, Italy, June 16–19, pp. 1482
–1487
.10.1109/MED.2014.696158520.
Chen
, W. L.
, Chen
, S. C.
, Chen
, C. C.
, Chou
, C. H.
, Shih
, Y. Y.
, Chen
, Y. L.
, and Kuo
, T. S.
, 2010
, “Patient-Driven Loop Control for Ambulation Function Restoration in a Non-Invasive Functional Electrical Stimulation System
,” Disability Rehabil.
, 32
(1
), pp. 65
–71
.10.3109/0963828090302656421.
Seel
, T.
, Werner
, C.
, and Schauer
, T.
, 2016
, “The Adaptive Drop Foot Stimulator - Multivariable Learning Control of Foot Pitch and Roll Motion in Paretic Gait
,” Med. Eng. Phys.
, 38
(11
), pp. 1205
–1213
.10.1016/j.medengphy.2016.06.00922.
Chen
, G.
, Shen
, Z.
, Zhuang
, Y.
, Wang
, X.
, and Song
, R.
, 2018
, “Intensity- and Duration-Adaptive Functional Electrical Stimulation Using Fuzzy Logic Control and a Linear Model for Dropfoot Correction
,” Front. Neurol.
, 9
, p. 165
.10.3389/fneur.2018.0016523.
Chen
, Y.-L.
, Li
, Y.-C.
, Kuo
, T.-S.
, and Lai
, J.-S.
, 2001
, “The Development of a Closed-Loop Controlled Functional Electrical Stimulation (FES) in Gait Training
,” J. Med. Eng. Technol.
, 25
(2
), pp. 41
–48
.10.1080/0309190011004361224.
Li
, Y.
, Yang
, X.
, Zhou
, Y.
, Chen
, J.
, Du
, M.
, and Yang
, Y.
, 2021
, “Adaptive Stimulation Profiles Modulation for Foot Drop Correction Using Functional Electrical Stimulation: A Proof of Concept Study
,” IEEE J. Biomed. Health Inform.
, 25
(1
), pp. 59
–68
.10.1109/JBHI.2020.298974725.
Melo
, P. L.
, Silva
, M. T.
, Martins
, J. M.
, and Newman
, D. J.
, 2015
, “Technical Developments of Functional Electrical Stimulation to Correct Drop Foot: Sensing, Actuation and Control Strategies
,” Clin. Biomech.
, 30
(2
), pp. 101
–113
.10.1016/j.clinbiomech.2014.11.00726.
Awad
, L. N.
, Reisman
, D. S.
, Kesar
, T. M.
, and Binder-Macleod
, S. A.
, 2014
, “Targeting Paretic Propulsion to Improve Poststroke Walking Function: A Preliminary Study
,” Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil.
, 95
(5
), pp. 840
–848
.10.1016/j.apmr.2013.12.01227.
Conway
, K. A.
, Bissette
, R. G.
, and Franz
, J. R.
, 2018
, “The Functional Utilization of Propulsive Capacity During Human Walking
,” J. Appl. Biomech.
, 34
(6
), pp. 474
–482
.10.1123/jab.2017-038928.
Awad
, L. N.
, Hsiao
, H.
, and Binder-Macleod
, S. A.
, 2020
, “Central Drive to the Paretic Ankle Plantarflexors Affects the Relationship Between Propulsion and Walking Speed After Stroke
,” J. Neurol. Phys. Ther.
, 44
(1
), pp. 42
–48
.10.1097/NPT.000000000000029929.
Dong
, H.
, Hou
, J.
, Song
, Z.
, Xu
, R.
, Meng
, L.
, and Ming
, D.
, 2022
, “An Adaptive Reflexive Control Strategy for Walking Assistance System Based on Functional Electrical Stimulation
,” Front. Neurosci.
, 16
, p. 944291
.10.3389/fnins.2022.94429130.
Donlin
, M. C.
, and Higginson
, J. S.
, 2024
, “Adaptive Functional Electrical Stimulation Delivers Stimulation Amplitudes Based on Real-Time Gait Biomechanics
,” ASME J. Med. Devices
, 18
(2
), p. 021002
.10.1115/1.406547931.
Ray
, N. T.
, Reisman
, D. S.
, and Higginson
, J. S.
, 2020
, “Walking Speed Changes in Response to User-Driven Treadmill Control After Stroke
,” J. Biomech.
, 101
, p. 109643
.10.1016/j.jbiomech.2020.10964332.
Ray
, N. T.
, Knarr
, B. A.
, and Higginson
, J. S.
, 2018
, “Walking Speed Changes in Response to Novel User-Driven Treadmill Control
,” J. Biomech.
, 78
, pp. 143
–149
.10.1016/j.jbiomech.2018.07.03533.
Kesar
, T. M.
, Perumal
, R.
, Jancosko
, A.
, Reisman
, D. S.
, Rudolph
, K. S.
, Higginson
, J. S.
, and Binder-Macleod
, S. A.
, 2010
, “Novel Patterns of Functional Electrical Stimulation Have an Immediate Effect on Dorsiflexor Muscle Function During Gait for People Poststroke
,” Phys. Ther.
, 90
(1
), pp. 55
–66
.10.2522/ptj.2009014034.
Hakansson
, N. A.
, Kesar
, T. M.
, Reisman
, D. S.
, Binder-Macleod
, S. A.
, and Higginson
, J. S.
, 2011
, “Effects of Fast Functional Electrical Stimulation Gait Training on Mechanical Recovery in Poststroke Gait
,” Artif. Organs
, 35
(3
), pp. 217
–220
.10.1111/j.1525-1594.2011.01215.x35.
Kerrigan
, D. C.
, Todd
, M. K.
, and Croce
, U. D.
, 1998
, “Gender Differences in Joint Biomechanics During Walking Normative Study in Young Adults
,” Am. J. Phys. Med. Rehabil.
, 77
(1
), pp. 2
–7
.10.1097/00002060-199801000-0000236.
Balaban
, B.
, and Tok
, F.
, 2014
, “Gait Disturbances in Patients With Stroke
,” Phys. Med. Rehabil.
, 6
(7
), pp. 635
–642
.10.1016/j.pmrj.2013.12.01737.
Burdett
, R.
, Borello-France
, D.
, Blatchly
, C.
, and Potter
, C.
, 2016
, “Gait Comparison of Subjects With Hemiplegia Walking Unbraced, With Ankle-Foot Orthosis, and With Air-Stirrup® Brace
,” Phys. Ther.
, 68
(8
), pp. 1197
–1203
.10.1093/ptj/68.8.119738.
Olney
, S. J.
, and Richards
, C.
, 1996
, “Hemiparetic Gait Following Stroke. Part I: Characteristics
,” Gait Posture
, 4
(2
), pp. 136
–148
.10.1016/0966-6362(96)01063-639.
Awad
, L. N.
, Kesar
, T. M.
, Reisman
, D.
, and Binder-Macleod
, S. A.
, 2013
, “Effects of Repeated Treadmill Testing and Electrical Stimulation on Post-Stroke Gait Kinematics
,” Gait Posture
, 37
(1
), pp. 67
–71
.10.1016/j.gaitpost.2012.06.00140.
McGraw
, K. O.
, and Wong
, S. P.
, 1992
, “A Common Language Effect Size Statistic
,” Psychol. Bull.
, 111
(2
), pp. 361
–365
.10.1037/0033-2909.111.2.36141.
Kempski
, K. M.
, Ray
, N. T.
, Knarr
, B. A.
, and Higginson
, J. S.
, 2019
, “Dynamic Structure of Variability in Joint Angles and Center of Mass Position During User-Driven Treadmill Walking
,” Gait Posture
, 71
, pp. 241
–244
.10.1016/j.gaitpost.2019.04.03142.
Donlin
, M. C.
, Pariser
, K. M.
, Downer
, K. E.
, and Higginson
, J. S.
, 2022
, “Adaptive Treadmill Walking Encourages Persistent Propulsion
,” Gait Posture
, 93
, pp. 246
–251
.10.1016/j.gaitpost.2022.02.01743.
Wonsetler
, E. C.
, and Bowden
, M. G.
, 2017
, “A Systematic Review of Mechanisms of Gait Speed Change Post-Stroke. Part 1: Spatiotemporal Parameters and Asymmetry Ratios
,” Top. Stroke Rehabil.
, 24
(6
), pp. 435
–446
.10.1080/10749357.2017.128574644.
Hsiao
, H.
, Knarr
, B. A.
, Higginson
, J. S.
, and Binder-Macleod
, S. A.
, 2015
, “Mechanisms to Increase Propulsive Force for Individuals Poststroke
,” J. NeuroEng. Rehabil.
, 12
(1
), Article No. 40.10.1186/s12984-015-0030-845.
Perry
, J.
, Garrett
, M.
, Gronley
, J. K.
, and Mulroy
, S. J.
, 1995
, “Classification of Walking Handicap in the Stroke Population
,” Stroke
, 26
(6
), pp. 982
–989
.10.1161/01.STR.26.6.98246.
Lewek
, M. D.
, and Sykes
, R.
, 2019
, “Minimal Detectable Change for Gait Speed Depends on Baseline Speed in Individuals With Chronic Stroke
,” J. Neurol. Phys. Ther.
, 43
(2
), pp. 122
–127
.10.1097/NPT.000000000000025747.
van de Port
, I. G.
, Kwakkel
, G.
, and Lindeman
, E.
, 2008
, “Community Ambulation in Patients With Chronic Stroke: How Is It Related to Gait Speed?
,” J. Rehabil. Med.
, 40
(1
), pp. 23
–27
.10.2340/16501977-011448.
Patterson
, K. K.
, Parafianowicz
, I.
, Danells
, C. J.
, Closson
, V.
, Verrier
, M. C.
, Staines
, W. R.
, Black
, S. E.
, and McIlroy
, W. E.
, 2008
, “Gait Asymmetry in Community-Ambulating Stroke Survivors
,” Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil.
, 89
(2
), pp. 304
–310
.10.1016/j.apmr.2007.08.14249.
Kesar
, T. M.
, Binder-Macleod
, S. A.
, Hicks
, G. E.
, and Reisman
, D. S.
, 2011
, “Minimal Detectable Change for Gait Variables Collected During Treadmill Walking in Individuals Post-Stroke
,” Gait Posture
, 33
(2
), pp. 314
–317
.10.1016/j.gaitpost.2010.11.02450.
Tilson
, J. K.
, Sullivan
, K. J.
, Cen
, S. Y.
, Rose
, D. K.
, Koradia
, C. H.
, Azen
, S. P.
, and Duncan
, P. W.
, and for the Locomotor Experience Applied Post Stroke (LEAPS) Investigative Team
, 2010
, “Meaningful Gait Speed Improvement During the First 60 Days Poststroke: Minimal Clinically Important Difference
,” Phys. Ther.
, 90
(2
), pp. 196
–208
.10.2522/ptj.2009007951.
Chui
, K.
, Hood
, E.
, and Klima
, D.
, 2012
, “Meaningful Change in Walking Speed
,” Top. Geriatr. Rehabil.
, 28
(2
), pp. 97
–103
.10.1097/TGR.0b013e318251019552.
Bohannon
, R. W.
, and Glenney
, S. S.
, 2014
, “Minimal Clinically Important Difference for Change in Comfortable Gait Speed of Adults With Pathology: A Systematic Review
,” J. Eval. Clin. Pract.
, 20
(4
), pp. 295
–300
.10.1111/jep.1215853.
Burke
, E.
, Dodakian
, L.
, See
, J.
, McKenzie
, A.
, Riley
, J. D.
, Le
, V.
, and Cramer
, S. C.
, 2014
, “A Multimodal Approach to Understanding Motor Impairment and Disability After Stroke
,” J. Neurol.
, 261
(6
), pp. 1178
–1186
.10.1007/s00415-014-7341-854.
Hsiao
, H.
, Knarr
, B. A.
, Higginson
, J. S.
, and Binder-Macleod
, S. A.
, 2015
, “The Relative Contribution of Ankle Moment and Trailing Limb Angle to Propulsive Force During Gait
,” Human Mov. Sci.
, 39
, pp. 212
–221
.10.1016/j.humov.2014.11.00855.
Kepple
, T. M.
, Siegel
, K. L.
, and Stanhope
, S. J.
, 1997
, “Relative Contributions of the Lower Extremity Joint Moments to Forward Progression and Support During Gait
,” Gait Posture
, 6
(1
), pp. 1
–8
.10.1016/S0966-6362(96)01094-656.
Parthasarathy
, A.
, V.n
, M.
, and Talasila
, V.
, 2020
, “Forecasting a Gait Cycle Parameter Region to Enable Optimal FES Triggering
,” IFAC-PapersOnLine
, 53
(1
), pp. 232
–239
.10.1016/j.ifacol.2020.06.04057.
Chen
, G.
, Ma
, L.
, Song
, R.
, Li
, L.
, Wang
, X.
, and Tong
, K.
, 2018
, “Speed-Adaptive Control of Functional Electrical Stimulation for Dropfoot Correction
,” J. NeuroEng. Rehabil.
, 15
(1
), Article No. 98.10.1186/s12984-018-0448-x58.
Skelly
, M. M.
, and Chizeck
, H. J.
, 2001
, “Real-Time Gait Event Detection for Paraplegic FES Walking
,” IEEE Trans. Neural Syst. Rehabil. Eng.
, 9
(1
), pp. 59
–68
.10.1109/7333.91827759.
Awad
, L. N.
, Reisman
, D. S.
, Wright
, T. R.
, Roos
, M. A.
, and Binder-Macleod
, S. A.
, 2014
, “Maximum Walking Speed Is a Key Determinant of Long Distance Walking Function After Stroke
,” Top. Stroke Rehabil.
, 21
(6
), pp. 502
–509
.10.1310/tsr2106-502
