Abstract

The third edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of the American Psychiatric Association (DSM-III) is evaluated from the standpoint of forensic science experience in a family court setting. The importance of diagnosis in developing pertinent recommendations within an adversarial system is discussed, with particular emphasis on difficulties in coordinating the Manual with the mental disorders frequently found in such a population. The limitations of the current criteria of the developmental disabilities are noted, and problems of reconciling incest and child abuse with the nomenclature are investigated. Some inconsistencies in the conceptualization of the conduct disorders and antisocial personality disorder are explored in terms of the needs of the juvenile justice system. An additional coding procedure is proposed for DSM-III, in order to identify more easily prodromal or emerging disorders of clinical significance.

Issue Section:
Research Papers
Keywords:
jurisprudence, psychiatry, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, family relations

References

1.
Schuster
,
R.
 and
Guggenheim
,
P.
, “
Focus of Clerical Practice in a Family Court Mental Health Service
,” in
Critical Issues in American Psychiatry and the Law
,
R.
 
Rosner
, Ed.,
Charles C Thomas
,
Springfield, IL
,
1982
.
2.
Lyskowski
,
J.
 and
Tsuang
,
M.
, “
Precautions in Treating DSM-III Borderline Personality Disorders
,”
American Journal of Psychiatry
 0002-953X, Vol.
137
, No.
1
,
01
1980
, pp.
521
-
525
.
3.
Schacht
,
T.
 and
Nathan
,
P.
, “
But Is It Good for Psychologists?
”
American Psychologist
 0003-066X, Vol.
32
,
1977
, pp.
1017
-
1025
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
 
4.
Spitzer
,
R.
,
Williams
,
J.
, and
Skodol
,
A.
, “
DSM-III: The Major Achievements and an Overview
,”
American Journal of Psychiatry
 0002-953X, Vol.
137
, No.
2
,
02
1980
, pp.
151
-
164
.
Google Scholar
PubMed
 
5.
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders
, (DSM-III), 3rd ed.,
The American Psychiatric Association
,
Washington, DC
,
1980
.
6.
Schuster
,
R.
 and
Guggenheim
,
P.
, “
An Investigation of the Intellectual Capabilities of Juvenile Offenders
,”
Journal of Forensic Sciences
 0022-1198, Vol.
27
, No.
2
,
04
1982
, pp.
393
-
400
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
PubMed
 
7.
Bryan
,
I.
 and
Bryan
,
J.
, “
Learning Disorders
,” in
Handbook of Minimal Brain Dysfunction: A Critical View
,
H.
 
Rie
 and
E.
 
Rie
, Eds.,
John Wiley and Sons
,
New York
,
1980
.
8.
Meier
,
J.
,
Developmental and Learning Disabilities
,
University Park Press
,
Baltimore
,
1976
.
9.
Waugh
,
K.
 and
Bush
,
W.
,
Diagnosing Learning Disorders
,
Charles E. Merrill
,
Columbus, OH
,
1971
.
10.
Frierson
,
E. C.
 and
Walter
,
B.
, Eds.,
Children with Learning Disabilities
,
Appleton-Century Crofts
,
New York
,
1967
.
11.
Rie
,
E.
, “
Effect of MBD on Learning, Intellective Functions, and Achievement
,” in
Handbook of Minimal Brain Dysfunction: A Critical View
,
H.
 
Rie
 and
E.
 
Rie
, Eds.,
John Wiley and Sons
,
New York
,
1980
.
12.
Bromberg
,
W.
,
The Uses of Psychiatry in the Law
,
Quorum Books
,
Westport, CT
,
1979
.
13.
MacDonald
,
J.
,
Psychiatry and the Criminal
,
Charles C Thomas
,
Springfield, IL
,
1976
.
14.
Kempe
,
C.
 and
Helfer
,
R.
, Eds.,
The Battered Child
, 3rd ed.,
University of Chicago
,
Chicago
,
1980
.
15.
Renvoize
,
J.
,
Uses of Violence
,
Routledge and Kegan Paul
,
Boston
,
1978
.
16.
Rosen
,
I.
,
Sexual Deviation
, 2nd ed.,
Oxford University Press
,
Oxford
,
1979
.
17.
Walters
,
D.
,
Physical and Sexual Abuse of Children
,
University of Indiana Press
,
Bloomington, IN
,
1975
.
18.
Gebhard
,
P.
,
Gagnon
,
J.
,
Pomeroy
,
W.
, and
Christianson
,
C.
,
Sex Offenders
,
Harper and Row
,
New York
,
1965
.
19.
Quinsey
,
V.
,
Chapin
,
T.
, and
Carrigan
,
W.
, “
Sexual Preferences among Incestuous and Nonincestuous Child Molesters
,”
Behavior Therapy
, Vol.
10
, No.
4
,
1978
, pp.
562
-
565
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
 
20.
Dixon
,
K.
,
Arnold
,
K.
, and
Calestro
,
K.
, “
Father-Son Incest: Underreported Pyschiatric Problem?
”
American Journal of Psychiatry
 0002-953X, Vol.
135
, No.
7
,
07
1978
, pp.
835
-
836
.
Google Scholar
PubMed
 
21.
Scott
,
W.
, “
Attachment and Child Abuse: A Study of Social History Indicators among Mothers of Abused Children
,” in
Traumatic Abuse and Neglect of Children at Home
,
G.
 
Williams
 and
J.
 
Money
, Eds.,
Johns Hopkins University
,
Baltimore
,
1980
.
22.
Aries
,
P.
,
Centuries of Childhood
,
Vintage Books
,
New York
,
1962
.
23.
Korbin
,
J.
, “
The Cross Cultural Context of Child Abuse
,” in
The Battered Child
, 3rd ed.,
C.
 
Kempe
 and
R.
 
Helfer
, Eds.,
University of Chicago Press
,
Chicago
,
1980
.
24.
Steele
,
B.
, “
Psychodynamic Factors in Child Abuse
,” in
The Battered Child
, 3rd ed.,
C.
 
Kempe
 and
R.
 
Helfer
, Eds.,
University of Chicago Press
,
Chicago
,
1980
.
25.
Spinetta
,
J.
 and
Rigles
,
D.
, “
The Child Abusing Parent: A Psychological Review
,” in
Traumatic Abuse and Neglect of Children at Home
,
G.
 
Williams
 and
J.
 
Money
, Eds.,
Johns Hopkins University
,
Baltimore
,
1980
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
 
26.
Wright
,
L.
, “
The ‘Sick but Slick’ Syndrome as a Personality Component of Parents of Battered Children
,” in
Traumatic Abuse and Neglect of Children at Home
,
G.
 
Williams
 and
J.
 
Money
, Eds.,
Johns Hopkins Press
,
Baltimore
,
1980
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
 
27.
Millon
,
T.
,
Disorders of Personality
,
John Wiley and Sons
,
New York
,
1981
.
28.
Lewis
,
D. O.
 and
Balla
,
D.
, “
‘Sociopathy’ and its Symptoms: Inappropriate Diagnosis in Child Psychiatry
,”
American Journal of Psychiatry
 0002-953X, Vol.
132
, No.
7
,
07
1975
, pp.
720
-
722
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
PubMed
 
29.
Jenkins
,
R.
,
Behavior Disorders in Childhood and Adolescence
,
Charles C Thomas
,
Springfield, Illinois
,
1973
.
30.
Robins
,
L.
, “
Sturdy Childhood Predictors of Adult Outcome: Replications from Longitudinal Studies
,”
Psychological Medicine
 0033-2917, Vol.
8
,
1978
, pp.
611
-
622
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
PubMed
 
31.
Robins
,
L.
, “
Aetiological Implications in Studies of Childhood Histories Relating to Antisocial Personality
,” in
Psychopathic Behavior: Approaches to Research
,
R.
 
Here
 and
D.
 
Schalling
, Eds.,
John Wiley and Sons
,
Chichester, England
,
1978
.
32.
Marohn
,
R.
, “
Personality Disorders and Adolescence
,” in
Personality Disorders
, 2nd ed.,
J.
 
Lion
, Ed.,
Williams and Wilkins
,
Baltimore
,
1981
.
33.
Neubauer
,
P.
, “
Normal Development in Children
,” in
Manual of Child Psychopathology
,
B.
 
Wolman
, Ed.,
McGraw-Hill
,
New York
,
1972
.
34.
Halleck
,
S.
,
The Politics of Therapy
,
Science House
,
New York
,
1971
.
35.
Reid
,
W.
, “
The Antisocial Personality and Related Symptoms
,” in
Personality Disorders
, 2nd ed.,
J.
 
Lion
, Ed.,
Williams and Wilkins
,
Baltimore
,
1981
.
36.
Wolfgang
,
M.
, “
Seriousness of Crime and a Policy of Juvenile Justice
,” in
Delinquency, Crime, and Society
,
J.
 
Short
, Ed.,
University of Chicago Press
,
Chicago
,
1976
.
37.
Guggenheim
,
P.
, “
Juvenile Justice—Changes in the N.Y.S. Law
,”
The Bulletin
, Vol.
22
, No.
1
,
1979
, pp.
2
-
7
.
38.
Guggenheim
,
P.
, “
The Juvenile Offender Law
,”
The Bulletin
, Vol.
25
, No.
6
,
1981
, pp.
1
-
3
.
This content is only available via PDF.
All rights reserved. This material may not be reproduced or copied, in whole or in part, in any printed, mechanical, electronic, film, or other distribution and storage media, without the written consent of ASTM International.
You do not currently have access to this content.