Abstract

A case of familicide by a 36-year-old male is reported. After years of stable marriage, exemplary military service, and steady employment, the subject developed his first episode of depression triggered, in part, by his inability to solve a problem associated with completion of a home improvement project. As the depression intensified, and dormant conflicts regarding his competency and self-esteem were rekindled, he experienced pronounced feelings of failure. After an extended period of agonizing about his problem, the idea suddenly emerged that his only recourse was to kill his family and himself, in order to spare everyone the humiliation of his perceived inadequacy. Such a fixed idea, along with a mounting pressure to act, is characteristic of the (chronic) catathymic process, in which a subject, without apparent motive, resorts to extreme violence directed at someone close to him. A detailed discussion of this case within the framework of catathymic process adds to our knowledge of family mass murder and refines the profile of potentially familicidal men.

References

1.
Guttmacher
M S
.
The mind of the murderer
.
New York
,
Strauss & Cudahy
,
1960
.
2.
Goldney
R D
.
Family murder followed by suicide
.
J Forensic Sci
1977
;
9
:
219
-
28
.
3.
Malmquist
C P
.
Psychiatric aspects of familicide
.
Bull Am Acad Psychiat Law
1980
;
8
:
298
-
304
.
4.
McGinniss
J
.
Fatal vision
.
New York
,
Signet
,
1983
.
5.
Levin
J
,
Fox
J A
.
Mass murder
.
New York
,
Plenum
.
1985
.
6.
Macdonald
J M
.
The murderer and his victims
.
Springfield, IL
,
Thomas
.
1986
.
7.
Graser
R R
.
Family murder in South Africa: some possible explanations
.
Acta Criminol
1992
;
5
:
75
-
80
.
8.
Stone
A A
.
Murder with no apparent motive
.
J Psychiat Law
1993
;
21
:
175
-
89
.
9.
Dietz
P E
.
Mass, serial and sensational homicides
.
Bull NY Acad Med
1986
;
62
:
477
-
91
.
10.
Wilson
M
,
Daly
M
,
Daniele
A
.
Familicide: the killing of spouse and children
.
Aggressive Behav
1995
;
21
:
275
-
91
.
11.
Daly
M
,
Wilson
M
.
Evolutionary social psychology and family homicide
.
Science
 1095-9203
1988
;
242
:
519
-
24
.
12.
Cooper
M
,
Eaves
D
.
Suicide following homicide in the family
.
Violence Victims
1996
;
11
:
99
-
112
.
13.
Ewing
C P
.
Fatal families: the dynamics of intrafamilial homicide
.
Thousand Oaks, CA
,
Sage
,
1997
.
14.
Morenz
B
,
Lane
R D
.
Morbid jealousy and criminal conduct
. In:
Schlesinger
L B
, editor.
Explorations in criminal psychopathology: clinical syndromes with forensic implications
.
Springfield, IL
,
Thomas
1996
;
78
-
97
.
15.
Schlesinger
L B
.
The catathymic crisis (1912-present): a review and clinical study
.
Aggression Violent Behav
1996
;
1
:
307
-
16
.
16.
Wertham
F
.
The catathymic crisis: a clinical entity
.
Arch Neurol Psychiat
1937
;
37
:
974
-
7
.
17.
Pallone
N J
,
Hennessy
J J
.
Criminal behavior
.
New Brunswick, NJ
,
Transaction
,
1994
.
18.
Revitch
E
,
Schlesinger
L B
.
Psychopathology of homicide
.
Springfield, IL
,
Thomas
,
1981
.
19.
Malmquist
C P
.
Homicide: a psychiatric perspective
.
Washington, DC
,
Amer Psychiat Press
,
1996
.
20.
Lesse
S
.
Masked depression
.
New York
,
Jason Aronson
,
1974
.
21.
Schlesinger
L B
.
The catathymic process: psychopathology and psychodynamics of extreme aggression
. In:
Schlesinger
L B
, editor.
Explorations in criminal psychopathology: clinical syndromes with forensic implications
.
Springfield, IL
,
Thomas
,
1996
:
121
-
41
.
22.
Wertham
F
.
The catathymic crisis
. In:
Kutash
I L
,
Kutash
S B
,
Schlesinger
L B
, editors.
Violence: perspectives on murder and aggression
.
San Francisco
,
Jossey-Bass
.
1978
;
165
-
70
.
23.
Revitch
E
,
Schlesinger
L B
.
Sex murder and sex aggression
.
Springfield, IL
,
Thomas
,
1989
.
24.
Krafft-Ebing
R von
.
Psychopathia sexualis
.
Philadelphia
,
PA Davis Co.
,
1868
.
25.
Ressler
R
,
Burgess
A W
,
Douglas
J E
.
Sexual homicide: patterns and motives
.
New York
,
Free Press
,
1988
.
26.
Jameison
G R
.
Suicide and mental disease: a clinical study of one hundred cases
.
Arch Neurol Psychiat
1936
;
36
:
1
-
12
.
27.
Revitch
E
,
Schlesinger
L B
.
Murder: evaluation, classification, and prediction
. In:
Kutash
I L
,
Kutash
S B
,
Schlesinger
L B
, editors.
Violence: perspectives on murder and aggression
.
San Francisco
,
Jossey-Bass
,
1978
;
138
-
64
.
28.
Rosenbaum
M
.
The role of depression in couples involved in murder-suicide and homicide
.
Am J Psychiat
1990
;
147
:
1036
-
9
.
29.
Milton
R
.
Are you seeing a mass killer?
Aust Physician
1992
;
21
:
739
-
43
.
30.
Goldney
R D
.
Family murder followed by suicide
.
J Forensic Sci
1977
;
9
:
219
-
28
.
31.
Rosenbaum
M
,
Bennett
B
.
Homicide and depression
.
Am J Psychiat
1986
;
143
:
367
-
70
.
32.
Abraham
K
.
Notes on the psychoanalytical investigation and treatment of manic-depressive insanity and allied conditions
. In:
Jones
E
, editor,
Selected papers of Karl Abraham
.
London
,
Hogarth
,
1927
;
137
-
56
.
33.
Freud
S
.
Mourning and melancholia
. In:
Strachey
J
, editor and translator.
The complete psychological works: standard edition
.
London
,
Hogarth
,
1917
;
14
:
239
-
58
.
34.
Marzuk
P M
,
Tardiff
K
,
Hirsch
C S
.
The epidemiology of murder-suicide
.
JAMA
1992
;
267
:
3179
-
82
.
35.
Litwack
T R
,
Schlesinger
L B
.
Dangerousness risk assessments: research, legal and clinical considerations
. In:
Hess
,
A K
,
Weiner
I B
, editors.
Handbook of forensic psychology
. 2nd ed.
New York
,
Wiley
,
1999
;
171
-
217
.
This content is only available via PDF.
You do not currently have access to this content.