Abstract

The performance of two commercial multiplex kits that together amplify the 13 core short tandem repeat (STR) loci currently in use by forensic laboratories and the U.S. national Combined DNA Indexing System (CODIS) were evaluated. The typing systems examined were AmpFℓSTR® Profiler Plus™ and AmpFℓSTR COfiler™ (PE Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA). Electrophoretic separation and detection of the fluorescent PCR products was achieved by capillary electrophoresis (CE) using an ABI Prism® 310 Genetic Analyzer. The studies addressed the on-site validation of the instrument, the software, and each typing system. These studies included instrument sensitivity, resolution, precision, binning, peak height ratios, mixtures, stutter, and the amplification of non-probative and simulated forensic samples. Other additional developmentaltype work is also reported herein, such as species specificity testing and amplification of environmentally insulted samples. Amplification conditions were found to be robust and the primer sets shown to be specific to human DNA. Stutter and peak height ratios fell within limits published by the manufacturer and other laboratories. The data demonstrate that the CE instrument can consistently resolve fragments differing in length by one base and that the ±0.5 base bin used by the Genotyper® software is acceptable for making accurate allele calls. Correct typing results were obtained from non-probative and simulated case samples, as well as samples exposed to outdoor environmental conditions. The results support the conclusion that DNA extracted from biological samples routinely encountered in the forensic laboratory can be reliably analyzed with AmpFℓSTR Profiler Plus and COfiler using CE.

References

1.
Budowle
B
.
Technical Working Group on DNA Analytical Methods
.
Guidelines for a quality assurance program for DNA analysis
.
Crime Lab Digest
1995
;
22
:
21
43
.
2.
DNA Advisory Board (DAB)
.
Federal Bureau of Investigation, U.S. Department of Justice
, Washington D.C.,
1998
.
3.
Gill
P
,
Sparkes
R
,
Fereday
L
,
Werrett
DJ
.
Report of the European Network of Forensic Science Institutes (ENSFI): formulation and testing of principles to evaluate STR multiplexes
.
Forensic Sci Int
 0379-0738
2000
;
108
:
1
29
.
4.
Blake
E
,
Mihalovich
J
,
Higuchi
R
,
Walsh
PS
,
Erlich
HA
.
Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification and human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-DQ αoligonucleotide typing on biological evidence samples: casework experience
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1993
;
37
:
700
26
.
5.
Budowle
B
,
Lindsey
JA
,
DeCou
JA
,
Koons
BW
,
Giusti
AM
,
Comey
CT
.
Validation and population studies of the loci LDLR, GYPA, HBGG, D7S8, and Gc (PM loci) and HLA-DQα using a multiplex amplification and typing procedure
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1995
;
40
:
45
54
.
6.
Cosso
S
,
Reynolds
R
.
Validation of the AmpliFLP™ D1S80 PCR amplification kit for forensic casework analysis according to TWGDAM guidelines
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1995
;
40
:
424
34
.
7.
Lins
AM
,
Sprecher
CJ
,
Puers
C
,
Schumm
JW
.
Multiplex sets for the amplification of polymorphic short tandem repeat loci—slver stain and fluorescent detection
.
Biotechniques
 0736-6205
1996
;
20
:
882
9
.
8.
Budowle
B
,
Moretti
TR
,
Keys
KM
,
Koons
BW
,
Smerick
JB
.
Validation studies of the CTT STR multiplex system
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1997
;
42
:
701
7
.
9.
Wallin
JM
,
Buoncristiani
MR
,
Lazaruk
KD
,
Fildes
N
,
Holt
CL
,
Walsh
PS
.
TWGDAM validation of the AmpFℓSTR Blue PCR amplification kit for forensic casework analysis
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1998
;
43
:
117
33
.
10.
Micka
KA
,
Amiott
EA
,
Hockenberry
Tl
,
Sprecher
CJ
,
lins
AM
,
Rabbach
DR
, et al
.
TWGDAM validation of a nine-locus and a four-locus fluorescent STR multiplex system
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1999
;
44
:
1243
57
.
11.
PE Applied Biosystems
.
AmpFℓSTR COfiler User Bulletin
. Foster City, CA,
1998
.
12.
PE Applied Biosystems
.
AmpFℓSTR Profiler Plus User's Manual. Version A
. Foster City, CA,
1997
.
13.
Cotton
EA
,
Allsop
RF
,
Guest
JL
,
Frazier
RRE
,
Koumi
P
,
Callow
IP
, et al
.
Validation of the AMPFℓSTR SGM Plus system for use in forensic casework
.
Forensic Sci Int
 0379-0738
2000
;
112
:
151
61
.
14.
Holt
CL
,
Buoncristiani
M
,
Wallin
JM
,
Nguyen
T
,
Lazaruk
KD
,
Walsh
PS
.
TWGDAM validation of AmpFℓSTRTM PCR amplification kits for forensic DNA casework
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
2002
;
47
:
66
96
.
15.
Wallin
JM
,
Holt
CL
,
Lazaruk
KD
,
Nguyen
TH
,
Walsh
PS
.
Constructing universal multiplex PCR systems for comparative genotyping
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
2002
;
47
:
52
65
.
16.
Pawlowski
R
,
Maciejewska
A
.
Forensic validation of a multiplex contained in nine STRs–population genetics in Northern Poland
.
Int J Legal Med
 0937-9827
2000
;
114
:
45
49
.
17.
Moretti
TR
,
Baumstark
AL
,
Defenbaugh
DA
,
Keys
KM
,
Smerick
JB
,
Budowle
B
.
Validation of short tandem repeats (STRs) for forensic usage: performance testing of fluorescent multiplex STR systems and analysis of authentic and simulated forensic samples
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
2001
;
46
: 647–60.
18.
Frank
WE
,
Llewellyn
BE
,
Fish
PE
,
Riech
AK
,
Marcacci
Tl
,
Gandor
DW
, et al
.
Validation of the AmpFℓSTR Profiler Plus PCR amplification kit for use in forensic casework
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
2001
;
46
:
642
6
.
19.
Budowle
B
,
Sprecher
CJ
.
Concordance study on population database samples using the PowerPlex 16 kit and AmpFℓSTR Profiler Plus kit and AmpFℓSTR COfiler kit
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
2001
;
46
:
637
41
.
20.
Budowle
B
,
Moretti
TR
,
Baumstark
AL
,
Defenbaugh
DA
,
Keys
KM
.
Population data on the thirteen CODIS core short tandem repeat loci in African Americans, U.S. Caucasians, Hispanics, Bahamians, Jamaicans, and Trinidadians
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1999
;
44
:
1277
86
.
21.
Holt
CL
,
Stauffer
C
,
Wallin
JM
,
Lazaruk
KD
,
Nguyen
T
,
Budowle
B
, et al
.
Practical applications of genotypic surveys for forensic STR testing
.
Forensic Sci Int
 0379-0738
2000
;
112
:
91
109
.
22.
Sacchetti
L
,
Calcagno
G
,
Coto
I
,
Tinto
N
,
Vuttariello
E
,
Salvatore
F
.
Efficiency of two different nine-loci short tandem repeat systems for DNA typing purposes
.
Clinical Chem
 0009-9147
1999
;
45
(
2
):
178
83
.
23.
Tomsey
CS
,
Kurtz
M
,
Kist
F
,
Hockensmith
M
,
Call
P
.
Comparison of PowerPlex 16, PowerPlex 1.1/2.1, and ABI AmpFℓSTR Profiler Plus/COfiler for forensic use
.
Croat Med J
 0353-9504
2001
;
42
(
3
):
239
43
.
24.
Budowle
B
,
Shea
B
,
Niezgoda
S
,
Chakraborty
R
.
CODIS STR loci data from 41 sample populations
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
2001
;
46
:
453
89
.
25.
LaFountain
MJ
,
Schwartz
MB
,
Svete
PA
,
Walkinshaw
MA
,
Buel
E
.
TWGDAM validation of the AmpFeSTR Profiler Plus and AmpFℓSTR COfiler multiplex systems using capillary electrophoresis
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
2001
;
46
:
1191
8
.
26.
Ruitberg
CM
,
Reeder
D
,
Butler
JM
.
STRBase: a short tandem repeat DNA database for the human identity testing community
.
Nucleic Acid Res
 0305-1048
2001
;
29
(
1
):
320
2
.
27.
Buel
E
,
Schwartz
MB
,
LaFountain
MJ
.
Capillary electrophoresis STR analysis: comparison to gel based systems
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1998
;
43
:
164
70
.
28.
Lazaruk
K
,
Walsh
PS
,
Oaks
F
,
Gilbert
D
,
Rosenblum
BD
,
Menchen
S
, et al
.
Genotyping of forensic short tandem repeat (STR) systems based on sizing precision in a capillary electrophoresis instrument
.
Electrophoresis Sci
1998
;
19
:
86
93
.
29.
Moretti
TR
,
Baumstark
AL
,
Defenbaugh
DA
,
Keys
KM
,
Brown
AL
,
Budowle
B
.
Validation of STR typing by capillary electrophoresis
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
2001
;
46
:
661
76
.
30.
Buel
E
,
LaFountain
M
,
Schwartz
M
,
Walkinshaw
M
.
Evaluation of capillary electrophoresis performance through resolution measurements
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
2001
;
46
:
341
45
.
31.
Hartmann
JM
,
Keister
RS
,
Luber
S
,
Baldwin
RA
,
White
JM
.
A DNA extraction and purification method used in the Orange County SheriffCoroner Department Crime laboratory
.
American Academy of Forensic Science
, Anaheim, CA,
1991
.
32.
Buse
E
,
Goodhart
S
.
Development of an economical and sensitive alkaline-phosphatase probe for human DNA quantitation
.
Proceedings from the fifth international symposium on human identification
,
Scottsdale, AZ
1994
;
163
4
.
33.
Walsh
PS
,
Valaro
J
,
Reynolds
R
.
A rapid chemiluminescent method for quantitation of human DNA
.
Nucleic Acids Res
 0305-1048
1992
;
20
:
5061
65
.
34.
Fregeau
CJ
,
Aubin
RA
,
Elliott
JC
,
Gill
SS
,
Fourney
RM
.
Characterization of human lymphoid cell lines GM9947 and GM9948 as intra- and inter-laboratory reference standards for DNA typing
.
Genomics
 0888-7543
1995
;
28
:
184
97
.
35.
Luckey
JA
,
Norris
TB
,
Smith
LM
.
Analysis of resolution in DNA sequencing by capillary gel electrophoresis
.
J Phys Chem
 0022-3654
1993
;
97
:
3067
75
.
36.
Biega
LA
,
Duceman
BW
.
Substitution of H2O for formamide in the sample preparation protocol for STR analysis using the capillary electrophoresis system: the effects on precision, resolution, and capillary life
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1999
;
44
:
1029
31
.
37.
Gill
P
,
Urquhart
A
,
Millican
E
,
Oldroyd
N
,
Watson
S
,
Sparkes
R
,et al
.
A new method of STR interpretation using inferential logic—evelopment of a criminal intelligence database
.
Int J Leg Med
 0937-9827
1996
;
109
: 14–22.
38.
Fregeau
CJ
,
Germain
O
,
Fourney
RM
.
Fingerprint enhancement revisited and the effects of blood enhancement chemicals on subsequent Profiler Plus fluorescent short tandem repeat DNA analysis of fresh and aged bloody fingerprints
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
2000
;
45
(
2
):
354
80
.
39.
Walsh
PS
,
Erlich
HA
,
Higuchi
R
.
Preferential PCR amplification of alleles: mechanisms and solutions
.
PCR Methods Appl
1992
;
1
:
241
50
.
40.
Magnuson
VL
,
Ally
D
,
Nylund
SJ
,
Karanjawala
ZE
,
Rayman
JB
,
Knapp
JI
, et al
.
Substrate nucleotide-determined non-templated addition of adenine by Taq DNA polymerase: implications for PCR based genotyping and cloning
.
Biotechniques
 0736-6205
1996
;
21
:
700
9
.
41.
Guttman
A
,
Schwartz
HE
.
Artifacts related to sample introduction in capillary electrophoresis affecting separation performance and quantitation
.
Anal Chem
 0003-2700
1995
;
67
:
2279
83
.
42.
Rosenblum
BB
,
Oaks
F
,
Menchen
S
,
Johnson
B
.
Improved single-strand DNA sizing accuracy in capillary electrophoresis
.
Nucleic Acids Res
 0305-1048
1997
;
25
(
19
):
3925
9
.
43.
Wenz
HM
,
Robertson
JM
,
Menchen
S
,
Oaks
F
,
Demorest
DM
,
Scheibler
D
, et al
.
High-precision genotyping by denaturing capillary electrophoresis
.
Genome Res
 1088-9051
1998
;
8
(
1
):
69
80
.
44.
Whitaker
JP
,
Cotton
EA
,
Gill
P
.
A comparison of the characteristics of profiles produced with AmpFℓSTR SGM Plus multiplex system for both standard and low copy number (LCN) STR DNA analysis
.
Forensic Sci Int
 0379-0738
2001
;
123
:
215
23
.
45.
Kline
MC
,
Jenkins
B
,
Rodgers
S
.
Non-amplification of a vWA allele
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1998
;
43
:250.
46.
Walsh
S
.
Commentary on Kline MC, Jenkins B, Rodgers S. Non-amplification of a vWA allele
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1998
;
43
:
1103
4
.
47.
Alves
C
,
Amorim
A
,
Gusmao
L
,
Pereira
L
.
VWA STR genotyping: further inconsistencies between Perkin-Elmer and Promega kits
.
Int J Leg Med
 0937-9827
2001
;
115
(
2
):
97
9
.
48.
Lazaruk
K
,
Wallin
J
,
Holt
C
,
Nguyen
T
,
Walsh
PS
.
Sequence variation in humans and other primates at six short tandem repeat loci used in forensic identity testing
.
Forensic Sci Int
 0379-0738
01
06
2001
;
119
(
1
):
1
10
.
49.
Walsh
PS
,
Fildes
NJ
,
Reynolds
R
.
Sequence analysis and characterization of stutter products at the tetranucleotide repeat locus vWA
.
Nucleic Acid Res
1996
;
24
(
14
):
2807
12
.
50.
Schlotterer
C
,
Tautz
D
.
Slippage synthesis of simple sequence DNA
.
Nucleic Acids Res
1992
;
20
(
2
):
211
5
.
51.
Brinkmann
B
,
Meyer
E
,
Junge
A
.
Complex mutational events at the HumD21S11 locus
.
Hum Genet
 0340-6717
1996
;
98
(
1
):
60
64
.
52.
Xiao
FX
,
Gilissen
A
,
Cassiman
JJ
,
Decorte
R
.
Quadraplex fluorescent STR typing system (HumVWA, HumTH01, D21S11 and HPRT) with sequence-defined allelic ladders. Identification of a new allele at D21S11
Forensic Sci Int
 0379-0738
1998
;
94
:
39
46
.
53.
Moller
A
,
Meyer
E
,
Brinkmann
B
.
Different types of structural variation in STRs: HumFES/FPS, HumVWA and HumD21S11
.
Int J Legal Med
 0937-9827
1994
;
106
(
6
):
319
23
.
54.
Tomsey
CS
,
Kurtz
M
,
Flowers
B
,
Fumea
J
,
Giles
B
,
Kucherer
S
.
Case work guidelines and interpretation of short tandem repeat complex mixture analysis
.
Croat Med J
 0353-9504 2001 Jun;
42
(
3
):
276
80
.
55.
Clayton
TM
,
Whitaker
JP
,
Sparkes
R
,
Gill
PD
.
Analysis and interpretation of mixed forensic stains using DNA STR profiling
.
Forensic Sci Int
 0379-0738
1998
;
91
:
55
70
.
56.
Gill
P
,
Sparkes
R
,
Pinchin
R
,
Clayton
T
,
Whittaker
J
,
Buckleton
JS
.
Interpreting simple STR mixtures using allele peak areas
.
Forensic Sci Int
 0379-0738
1998
;
91
:
41
53
.
57.
Fregeau
CJ
,
Bowen
KL
,
Fourney
RM
.
Validation of highly polymorphic fluorescent multiplex short tandem repeat systems using two generations of DNA sequencers
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1999
;
44
:
133
66
.
58.
Crouse
CA
,
Schumm
JW
.
Investigation of species specificity using nine PCR-based-human STR systems
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1995
;
40
:
952
6
.
59.
Buel
E
,
Wang
G
,
Schwartz
M
.
PCR amplification of animal DNA with human X-Y amelogenin primers used in gender determination
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1995
;
40
:
641
4
.
60.
Nelson
MS
,
Levedakou
EN
,
Matthews
JR
,
Early
BE
,
Freeman
DA
,
Kuhn
CA
, et al
.
Detection of a primer-binding site polymorphism for the STR locus D16S539 using the Powerplex 1.1 system and validation of a degenerate primer to correct for the polymorphism
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
2002
;
47
:
345
49
.
This content is only available via PDF.
You do not currently have access to this content.