Abstract

Evidentiary urine samples (n = 345) stored frozen at -20°C in their original containers (leakproof 100 mL plastic bottles) upon retesting for ethanol resulted in concentrations that were significantly lower (average loss = ~30%) than those prior to their storage at -20°C (p ~ 0.0001). The observed loss of ethanol was independent of the method of thawing or the concentration of ethanol in the samples, but was dependent on the sample volume in the container, i.e., the larger the volume of sample the larger the magnitude of ethanol loss. The loss of ethanol was determined to be due to improper sealing by a Styrofoam integrity seal attached to the mouth of the container. Accordingly, adopting leakproof plastic containers that do not contain Styrofoam integrity seals, but rather an outside and across the cap tape integrity seal for evidence collection and longterm storage, will prevent loss of ethanol due to evaporation.

References

1.
Garriott
,
JC
, editor.
Medicolegal aspects of alcohol
, 3rd ed.
Tucson, AZ
:
Lawyers & Judges Publishing Co.
,
1996
;p268.
2.
Plueckhan
VD
,
Ballard
B
.
Factors influencing the significance of alcohol concentrations in autopsy blood samples
.
The Med J Australia
1968
;
1
:
939
43
.
3.
Glendening
BL
,
Waugh
TC
.
The stability of ordinary blood alcohol samples held various periods of time under different conditions
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1965
;
10
:
192
200
.
4.
Dick
GL
,
Stone
H
.
Alcohol loss arising from microbial contamination of drivers' blood specimens
.
Forensic Sci Intl
1987
;
34
:
17
27
.
5.
Lough
PS
,
Fehn
R
.
Efficacy of 1% sodium fluoride as a preservative in urine samples containing glucose and Candida albicans
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1993
;
38
:
266
71
.
6.
Sulkowski
HA
,
Wu
AHB
,
McCarter
YS
.
In-vitro production of ethanol in urine by fermentation
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1995
;
40
:
990
3
.
7.
Jones
AW
,
Hylen
L
,
Svensson
E
,
Helander
A
.
Storage of specimens at 4°C or addition of sodium fluoride (1%) prevents formation of ethanol in urine inoculated with Candida albicans
.
J Anal Toxicol
 0146-4760
1999
;
23
: 333–6.
8.
Amick
GD
,
Habben
KH
.
Inhibition of ethanol production by Saccharomyces cerevisiae in human blood by sodium fluoride
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1997
;
42
:
690
2
.
9.
Jones
AW
.
Determination of liquid/air partition coefficients for dilute solutions of ethanol in water, whole blood, and plasma
.
J Anal Toxicol
 0146-4760
1983
;
7
:
193
7
.
10.
Jones
AW
.
Salting-out effect of sodium fluoride and its influence on the analysis of ethanol by headspace gas chromatography
.
J Anal Toxicol
 0146-4760
1994
;
18
:
292
3
.
11.
Solanky
AA
.
Effect of different concentrations of sodium fluoride on blood alcohol determination by headspace gas chromatography using the internal standard method
.
J Anal Toxicol
 0146-4760
1994
;
18
:63.
12.
Watts
MT
,
McDonald
OL
.
The effect of biologic specimen type on the gas chromatographic headspace analysis of ethanol and other volatile compounds
.
Am J Clin Pathol
 0002-9173
1987
;
87
:
79
85
.
13.
Sreerama
L
,
Nelson
JK
,
Meyer
RF
,
Hardin
GG
.
Influence of sodium fluoride (NaF) concentration on quantitative analysis of ethanol by headspace gas chromatography (HSGC) in urine samples
.
Proc Soc Forensic Toxicologists
,
2000
.
14.
Hayden
PM
,
Layden
MT
,
Hickey
MD
.
The stability of alcohol content in samples of blood and urine
.
Ir J Med Sci
1977
;
146
:
48
53
.
15.
Neuteboom
W
,
Zweipfenning
PGM
.
The stability of alcohol concentration in urine specimens
.
J Anal Toxicol
 0146-4760
1989
;
13
:
141
3
.
16.
Anthony
RM
,
Sutheimer
CA
,
Sunshine
I
.
Acetaldehyde, methanol, and ethanol analysis by head space gas chromatography
.
J Anal Toxicol
 0146-4760
1979
;
4
:
43
5
.
17.
Hardin
GG
.
Postmortem blood and vitreous humor ethanol concentrations in a victim of a fatal motor vehicle crash
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
2002
;
47
: 402–3.
18.
Sreerama
L
,
Gallagher
S
,
Pulju
P
,
Hardin
GG
.
Comparison of ethyl alcohol concentrations in simultaneously collected blood, breath, and urine samples: a field study
.
Proc Soc Forensic Toxicologists
,
2000
.
19.
Sreerama
L
,
Ukestad
EL
,
Meyer
RF
,
Hardin
GG
.
Comparison of ethyl alcohol concentrations in simultaneously collected blood, breath, and urine samples
.
Proc Amer Acad Forensic Sci
2000
;
6
:
280
1
.
This content is only available via PDF.
You do not currently have access to this content.