Searching for biological analogies appropriate for design problems is a core process of biologically inspired design (BID). Through in situ observations of student BIDs, we discovered that student designers struggle with two issues that bookend the problem of search: design problem formulation, which generates the set of conditions to be used for search; and evaluation of the appropriateness of the retrieved analogies, which depends both on problem formulation and the retrieved analogy. We describe a method for problem formulation and analogy evaluation in BID that we call the Four-Box method. We show that the Four-Box method can be rapidly and accurately used by designers for both problem formulation and analogy evaluation, and that designers find the method valuable for the intended tasks.
Issue Section:
Analogy Evaluation
References
1.
Chakrabarti
, A.
, Sarkar
, P.
, Leelavathamma
, B.
, and Nataraju
, B.
, 2005
, “A Functional Representation for Aiding Biomimetic and Artificial Inspiration of New Ideas
,” Artif. Intell. Eng. Des. Anal. Manuf.
, 19
, pp. 113
–132
.10.1017/S08900604050501092.
Chiu
, I.
, and Shu
, L. H.
, 2007
, “Biomimetic Design Through Natural Language Analysis to Facilitate Cross-Domain Information Retrieval
,” Artif. Intell. Eng. Des. Anal. Manuf.
, 21
, pp. 45
–59
.10.1017/S08900604070701383.
Nagel
, J.
, Stone
, R.
, and McAdams
, D.
, 2010
, “An Engineering-to-Biology Thesaurus for Engineering Design
,” ASME
Paper No. DETC2010-28233, Montreal
, Canada
.10.1115/DETC2010-282334.
Vattam
, S.
, and Goel
, A.
, 2011
, “Foraging for Inspiration: Understanding and Supporting the Information Seeking Practices of Biologically Inspired Designers
,” Proceedings of ASME IDETC Conference on Design Theory and Methods
, Washington
, DC
, Aug. 28–31.5.
Vincent
, J. F. V.
, Bogatyreva
, O. A.
, Bogatyrev
, N. R.
, Bowyer
, A.
, and Pahl
, A.-K.
, 2006
, “Biomimetics: Its Practice and Theory
,” J. R. Soc. Interface
, 3
(9
), pp. 471
–482.10.1098/rsif.2006.01276.
Helms
, M.
, Vattam
, S.
, and Goel
, A.
, 2009
, “Biologically Inspired Design: Process and Products
,” Des. Stud.
, 30
(5
), pp. 606
–622
.10.1016/j.destud.2009.04.0037.
Wirth
, N.
, 1971
, “Program Development by Stepwise Refinement
,” Commun. ACM
, 14
(4
), pp. 221
–227
.10.1145/362575.3625778.
Dahl
, O.
, Dykstra
, E.
, and Hoare
, C.
, 1972
, Structured Programming
, Academic
, New York
.9.
Roozenburg
, N.
, and Eekels
, J.
, 1995
, Product Design: Fundamentals and Methods
, Wiley
, Chichester, UK
.10.
Pahl
, G.
, Beitz
, W.
, Feldhusen
, J.
, and Grote
, J.-H.
, 2007
, Engineering Design
(K. Wallace and L. Blessing, Translators), The Design Council
, London, UK
.11.
Yen
, J.
, Weissburg
, M.
, Helms
, M.
, and Goel
, A.
, 2011
, “Biologically Inspired Design: A Tool for Interdisciplinary Education
,” Biomimetics: Nature-Based Innovation
, Y.
Bar-Cohen
, ed., Taylor & Francis
, London, UK
.12.
Yen
, J.
, Helms
, M.
, Goel
, A.
, Tovey
, C.
, and Weissburg
, M.
, 2013
, “Adaptive Evolution of Teaching Practices in Biologically Inspired Design
,” Biologically Inspired Design: Computational Methods and Tools
, A.
Goel
, D.
McAdams
, and R.
Stone
, eds., Springer
, London, UK
.13.
Chandrasekaran
, B.
, 1990
, “Design Problem Solving: A Task Analysis
,” AI Mag.
, 11
(4
), p. 59.14.
Darke
, J.
, 1979
, “The Primary Generator and the Design Process
,” Des. Stud.
, 1
(1
), pp. 36
–44
.10.1016/0142-694X(79)90027-915.
Dorst
, K.
, 2003
, “The Problem of Design Problems
,” Expertise in Design
, N.
Cross
and E.
Edmonds
, eds., Creativity and Cognition Studio Press
, Sydney
, pp. 135
–147
.16.
Dorst
, K.
, and Cross
, N.
, 2001
, “Creativity in the Design Process: Co-Evolution of Problem-Solution
,” Des. Stud.
, 22
(5
), pp. 425
–437
.10.1016/S0142-694X(01)00009-617.
Gero
, J.
, 1996
, “Creativity, Emergence and Evolution in Design
,” Knowl.-Based Syst.
, 9
(7
), pp. 435
–448
.10.1016/S0950-7051(96)01054-418.
Goel
, V.
, and Pirolli
, P.
, 1992
, “The Structure of Design Problem Spaces
,” Cogn. Sci.
, 16
, pp. 395
–429
.10.1207/s15516709cog1603_319.
Helms
, M.
, and Goel
, A.
, 2012
, “Analogical Problem Evolution in Biologically Inspired Design
,” Proceedings of Fifth International Conference on Design Computing and Cognition
, College Station
, TX
, June 7–9.20.
Ho
, C.-H.
, 2001
, “Some Phenomena of Problem Decomposition Strategy for Design Thinking: Differences Between Novices and Experts
,” Des. Stud.
, 22
(1
), pp. 27
–45
.10.1016/S0142-694X(99)00030-721.
Liikkanen
, L.
, and Perttula
, M.
, 2008
, “Exploring Problem Decomposition in Conceptual Design Among Novice Designers
,” Des. Stud.
, 30
(1
), pp. 38
–59
.10.1016/j.destud.2008.07.00322.
Lloyd
, P.
, and Scott
, P.
, 1994
, “Discovering the Design Problem
,” Des. Stud.
, 15
(2
), pp. 125
–140
.10.1016/0142-694X(94)90020-523.
Maher
, M. L.
, Poon
, J.
, and Boulanger
, S.
, 1996
, “Formalising Design Exploration as Co-Evolution: A Combined Gene Approach
,” Advances in Formal Design Methods for CAD
, J. S.
Gero
and F.
Sudweeks
, eds., Chapman and Hall
, London, UK
.24.
Restrepo
, J.
, and Christiaans
, H.
, 2003
, “Problem Structuring and Information Access in Design
,” Proceedings of the Expertise in Design: Design Thinking Research Symposium, N. Cross, and E. Edmonds (Eds.), Sydney Australia, pp. 149–162.25.
Schön
, D. A.
, 1983
, The Reflective Practitioner
, Temple-Smith
, London, UK
.26.
Gero
, J.
, 1993
, “Towards a Model of Exploration in Computer-Aided Design
,” Formal Design Methods for Computer-Aided Design
, J. S.
Gero
and N.
Tyugu
, eds., North-Holland
, Amsterdam
.27.
Simon
, H.
, 1973
, “The Structure of Ill-Structured Problems
,” Artif. Intell.
, 4
(3–4)
, pp. 181
–201
.10.1016/0004-3702(73)90011-828.
Gero
, J.
, and Kannengiesser
, U.
, 2004
, “The Situated Function-Behaviour-Structure Framework
,” Des. Stud.
, 25
(4
), pp. 373
–391
.10.1016/j.destud.2003.10.01029.
Goel
, A.
, 1992
, “Representation of Design Functions in Experience-Based Design
,” Intelligent Computer Aided Design
, D.
Brown
, M.
Waldron
, and H.
Yoshikawa
, eds., North-Holland, Amsterdam
, The Netherlands
, pp. 283
–308
.30.
Goel
, A.
, 2013
, “A 30-Year Case Study and 15 Principles: Implications of an Artificial Intelligence Methodology for Functional Modeling
,” Artif. Intell. Eng. Des. Anal. Manuf.
, 27
, pp. 203–215.31.
Goel
, A.
, and Bhatta
, S.
, 2004
, “Use of Design Patterns in Analogy-Based Design
,” Adv. Eng. Inf.
, 18
(2
), pp. 85
–94
.10.1016/j.aei.2004.09.00332.
Sarkar
, P.
, and Chakrabarti
, A.
, 2008
, “The Effect of Representation of Triggers on Design Outcomes
,” Artif. Intell. Des., Anal. Manuf.
, 22
(2
), pp. 101
–116
.10.1017/S089006040800007333.
Helms
, M.
, and Goel
, A.
, 2013
, “Grounded Knowledge Representations for Biologically Inspired Design
,” DS 75-6: Proceedings of the 19th International Conference on Engineering Design (ICED13)
, Design Society
, Seoul, Korea, Aug. 19–22, Vol. 6
, pp. 351
–360
.34.
Dinar
, M.
, Shah
, J.
, Hunt
, G.
, Campana
, E.
, and Langley
, P.
, 2011
, “Towards a Formal Representation Model of Problem Formulation in Design
,” ASME
Paper No. DETC2011-48396.10.1115/DETC2011-4839635.
Forbus
, K.
, Gentner
, D.
, and Law
, K.
, 1995
, “MAC/FAC: A Model of Similarity-Based Retrieval
,” Cogn. Sci.
, 19
(2
), pp. 141
–205
.10.1207/s15516709cog1902_136.
Gentner
, D.
, 1983
, “Structure-Mapping: A Theoretical Framework for Analogy
,” Cogn. Sci.
, 7
(2
), pp. 155
–170
.10.1207/s15516709cog0702_337.
Holyoak
, K.
, and Thagard
, P.
, 1995
, Mental Leaps: Analogy in Creative Thought
, MIT
, Cambridge, MA
.38.
Thagard
, P.
, Holyoak
, K. J.
, Nelson
, G.
, and Gochfeld
, D.
, 1990
, “Analog Retrieval by Constraint Satisfaction
,” Artif. Intell.
, 46
, pp. 259
–310
.10.1016/0004-3702(90)90018-U39.
Yaner
, P.
, and Goel
, A.
, 2006
, “Visual Analogy: Viewing Retrieval and Mapping as Constraint Satisfaction
,” J. Appl. Intell.
, 25
(1
), pp. 91
–105
.10.1007/s10489-006-8868-x40.
Goel
, A.
, Rugaber
, S.
, and Vattam
, S.
, 2009
, “Structure, Behavior, and Function of Complex Systems: The Structure, Behavior, and Function Modeling Language
,” Artif. Intell. Des., Anal. Manuf.
, 23
(1
), pp. 23
–35
.10.1017/S089006040900008041.
Goel
, A. K.
, Vattam
, S.
, Wiltgen
, B.
, and Helms
, M.
, 2012
, “Cognitive, Collaborative, Conceptual and Creative—Four Characteristics of the Next Generation of Knowledge-Based CAD Systems: A Study in Biologically Inspired Design
,” Comput.-Aided Des.
, 44
(10
), pp. 879
–900
.42.
Glaser
, B. G.
, and Strauss
, A. L.
, 2009
, The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research
, Transaction Books, Piscataway, NJ.43.
Strauss
, A. L.
, and Corbin
, J.
, 1990
, Basics of Qualitative Research
, Vol. 15
, Sage Publications, Newbury
Park, CA
.44.
Lamp
, J.
, and Milton
, S.
, 2007
, “Grounded Theory as Foundations for Methods in Applied Ontology
,” Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Qualitative Research in IT & IT in Qualitative Research (QualIT)
, Victoria University of Wellington
, Wellington, New Zealand, Nov. 18–20.45.
Helms
, M.
, 2013
, “Analogical Problem Evolution in Biologically Inspired Design
,” Doctoral dissertation, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta
, GA
.Copyright © 2014 by ASME
You do not currently have access to this content.
